Joel Jamin Wentling
Joel Jamin Wentling, age 51, of Greenville passed away Saturday morning October 12, 2019 at his home after an 8 month long fight with pancreatic cancer. Every single day he received input from friends and family, who wished him well and boosted his spirits. He truly got to see examples of the best in humanity and was so grateful for that. Joel was born in Greenville on September 29, 1968 to Dallas and Joan Wentling. Following graduation from Greenville High School in 1987, he began his studies in secondary education, specifically social studies, at Grove City College graduating in 1991. He played defensive tackle for the Wolverines, was captain and a 4 year starter. After college, he began a position he enjoyed immensely, for 2 years he worked as a teacher and counselor of troubled youth for Vision Quest, based in Franklin, PA. Vision Quest operated a unique "wagon train" program that gave troubled young adults the extraordinary experience of traveling 1000 miles across country on horseback or covered wagon. He helped the kids develop self-confidence, patience, and coping skills. In 1993, he began teaching 8th grade social studies at Reynolds High School. At this time, he obtained his masters degree in education at Westminister College including certificates in guidance counseling and secondary administration. In 1997, he began his 22-year stint as principal and assistant principal working at Conneaut Valley High School and Conneaut Lake Middle School. He was also a member of the Pennsylvania Association of Student Assistant Professionals and on the state board for 22 years. He also served on the Crawford County Children's Advocacy Council. He loved his students and thought it was important to understand kids, respect them and have relationships with them. He always said "Principal ends in PAL". Joel shared his passion for the outdoors with his family. Over the years, they spent many hours fishing, hunting whitetail, turkey, groundhogs, pheasants and grouse with his dog "Willy". He attended Zion's Reformed United Church of Christ where he was very involved as an elder, deacon, Sunday school teacher and choir member. He also enjoyed serving meals at the Good Shepard Center. On September 4, 1998, Joel married the former Michelle McClimans, she survives. He is also survived by his parents of Greenville; his son Jamin Wentling, daughter Mesa Wentling and son Justin Lewis and his wife Kylee all of Greenville; brother Kyle Wentling and his fiance Amanda Boggs and her children Gavin and Peyton, brother Parke Wentling and his wife Jennifer; nephews Bryer and Trap Wentling; nieces Ada and Iris Wentling; grandchildren Lincoln and Lexi Lewis all of Greenville. He was preceded in death by his uncle Rodney Wentling.

SERVICES: A Memorial Service will be held at 9:30 AM on Saturday 10-19-19 in Zion's Reformed United Church of Christ with Rev. June Boutwell, Pastor of the church officiating. Family and friends may call Friday 10-18-19 from 4:00-8:00 PM in Anderson Lounge of Zion's Reformed United Church of Christ. Memorial contributions may be made to Good Shepard Center, 10 N. Water St., Greenville, PA 16125. Arrangements have been entrusted to Loutzenhiser-Jordan Funeral Home and Cremation Services Inc. 366-368 S. Main St. Greenville. Visitors may sign the online guest book and view a video tribute at
Published on October 14, 2019


Plant a tree in memory
of Joel
Plant a tree

Obituary published in


Print Guestbook

A place to share condolences and memories.
The guestbook expires on January 11, 2020.

Showing 10 of 4 posts

Oct 16, 2019
I remember when he was our Vice Principal at Conneaut Valley H.S. he was very intimidating to many but I really liked him and he was understanding. He was so nice and knew how to approach situations and students. I preferred him over our lead principal. I was shocked to see this and devastated even though it's been years. He will be missed and may he rest in peace, my condolences to his family and friends.
Kevin Webber
Oct 16, 2019
My sincerest condolences go out to the Wentling Family. I had the privilege of working with Joel in his work to implement School-Wide PBIS at Conneaut Lake MS, and most recently through SAP. There was never a shortage of discussion when we met, and I will think upon our exchanges with fond memories.
Oct 14, 2019
Simply Elegant Spathiphyllum was purchased for the family of Joel Jamin Wentling.  Send flowers
Oct 14, 2019
Joel had a huge heart for his students! I enjoyed working with him in the Conneaut School District and sharing some memorable hunts as well. While we have lost a great caring empathetic compassionate man ... Heaven has gained an angel. Prayers for his family and friends who must continue their journeys without Joel ...May they all reflect on positive memories of Joel to see them through this difficult time 🙏